The short answer
EMDR has strong evidence for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and NICE recommends it for that. For borderline personality disorder itself, the evidence is promising but early. A 2025 Dutch trial found that EMDR on its own reduced both PTSD and BPD symptoms in people who had both. Smaller studies point the same way. No trial has yet tested EMDR as a stand-alone treatment for BPD without trauma, so it makes most sense as one part of a wider plan.
If you have borderline personality disorder (BPD), written as emotionally unstable personality disorder (EUPD) in many NHS letters, you may have heard EMDR described as a breakthrough, or as something to avoid. Neither claim matches the research. This post looks at what the studies tested, who took part, and how to judge whether EMDR makes sense for you.
Start hereEMDR for BPD and complex traumaWhat EMDR is, a session step by step, and how I use itWhat would "working" mean for BPD?
Before reading any study, it helps to ask what it measured. EMDR was built to treat trauma memories, so most trials measure PTSD symptoms: flashbacks, nightmares, feeling on guard, avoiding reminders. A smaller number also track BPD symptoms, such as mood swings, fear of being left or self-harm urges.
Those are different targets. A therapy can calm flashbacks a great deal and leave the fear of abandonment where it was. It can also help both, if the fear grew out of what happened to you. So when someone says EMDR "works for BPD", the fair question is: works on which part, for whom, and compared with what?
What the main studies found
Here are the studies most often quoted, with what each one can and can't tell you.
| Study | Who took part | What it found | The catch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Snoek and others, 2025, Netherlands | 124 adults with PTSD and at least four BPD symptoms | EMDR alone and EMDR with DBT both brought large drops in PTSD and BPD symptoms over a year, with no clear gap between them | Everyone had PTSD; it tells us little about BPD without trauma |
| Hafkemeijer and others, 2020, Netherlands | 97 outpatients with a personality disorder of any type, PTSD excluded | Five 90-minute EMDR sessions beat a waiting list on symptoms and personality functioning, holding at three months | Not a BPD-only group, and the comparison was a waiting list |
| De Jongh and others, 2020, Netherlands | 72 people with severe PTSD, 35 of whom screened positive for BPD | An eight-day intensive programme of EMDR and exposure therapy cut BPD symptoms, with no dropouts | No comparison group, and EMDR was mixed with other methods |
| Nvo-Fernández and others, 2025 | People with BPD, EMDR against CBT | Both groups improved, with no clear difference | 76 enrolled but only 18 finished, far too few to be sure |
Read together, these studies say something useful. For people who have BPD symptoms and trauma, EMDR can ease both, and it seems safer than many clinicians once assumed. They don't show that EMDR treats BPD in people whose difficulties aren't tied to trauma memories.
Is it safe to do EMDR when you have BPD?
For years, the common advice was to hold back trauma therapy until someone with BPD had spent months on stabilisation, meaning skills for calming down and staying safe. The Dutch studies challenge that. In the eight-day programme, nobody dropped out and nobody got worse. In the 2025 trial, people who had EMDR alone did as well as those who also had DBT, and those in the combined group were twice as likely to drop out of their EMDR.
That doesn't mean anyone can start trauma work tomorrow. Those programmes ran inside specialist teams, with people on hand every day. Working on my own, without a team behind me, I still make sure you can bring yourself down from a spike, and that we have a safety plan, before we process a memory. For some people that takes a few sessions. For others, longer.
Signs that EMDR may help you
EMDR tends to make the most sense when the past still feels present. These are the patterns I look for:
- A memory that replays in pictures, sounds or body feelings, as if it's happening again
- Nightmares, or jumping at reminders you can name
- Reactions in relationships that you can trace back to particular events
- A belief such as "I'm unlovable" that feels tied to specific times in your life
- Skills have given you some steadiness, but the old reactions keep firing
If your hardest times are about emptiness, identity or impulsivity, with no clear link to trauma memories, skills work or schema-informed therapy may come first. Your NHS team, or a free call with me, can help you sort that out.
What EMDR doesn't replace
NICE's guideline for BPD, CG78, asks for therapy that lasts more than three months, inside a clear plan. Five sessions of EMDR, however helpful, isn't that plan on its own. EMDR also won't teach you what to do with an urge at 2am, or how to repair a row with someone you love. Those come from skills practice and relational work.
If you have frequent self-harm, the treatment with the strongest backing is still a full DBT programme. The 2020 Cochrane review of 75 trials found DBT and mentalisation-based therapy beneficial, though the evidence was low certainty. If EMDR is offered, ask how it fits alongside that.
Questions to ask an EMDR therapist
- Have you used EMDR with people who have BPD or EUPD, and how did you adapt it?
- How will you decide when I'm ready to start processing?
- What happens if I dissociate, or feel worse for a few days afterwards?
- How does EMDR fit with the rest of my plan, and with my NHS care?
A good answer is specific. Be cautious about anyone who promises that a handful of sessions will clear BPD.
What this means for you
If trauma sits underneath your BPD, EMDR is worth discussing. The research gives reasons for hope, and for patience. I use EMDR as one part of an integrative plan, after we've built some steadiness, and always alongside your GP or NHS team, never instead of them. You can read how I decide when EMDR comes in, or what working with me looks like.
Questions people ask about EMDR and BPD
Is EMDR recommended for BPD in the UK?
Not as a treatment for BPD itself. NICE's PTSD guideline recommends EMDR for adults with PTSD. If you have BPD and PTSD, your team may offer it for the PTSD.
Can EMDR make BPD worse?
Recent Dutch studies found few dropouts and no worsening when EMDR was used with people who had BPD symptoms and PTSD. Memories and dreams can stir for a few days after a session. Preparation and a safety plan make that easier to handle.
Do I need a PTSD diagnosis to try EMDR?
No. Many people carry painful memories that never led to a PTSD diagnosis. What matters is whether particular memories still drive how you feel and react today.
Is EMDR better than DBT for BPD?
They do different jobs. DBT has the stronger evidence for BPD and for self-harm. EMDR targets trauma memories. Some people benefit from both, at different stages.
Sources
- Snoek AC and others (2025). Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing with and without dialectical behavior therapy for PTSD and comorbid BPD symptoms: a randomized controlled trial. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 94(3).
- Hafkemeijer L and others (2020). Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) in patients with a personality disorder. European Journal of Psychotraumatology 11(1).
- De Jongh A and others (2020). The impact of brief intensive trauma-focused treatment for PTSD on symptoms of borderline personality disorder. European Journal of Psychotraumatology 11(1).
- Nvo-Fernández M and others (2025). Effectiveness of EMDR in treating borderline personality disorder: a randomized controlled trial. Alpha Psychiatry 26(2).
- NICE (2018). Post-traumatic stress disorder (NG116).
- NICE (2009). Borderline personality disorder: recognition and management (CG78).
- Storebø OJ and others (2020). Psychological therapies for people with borderline personality disorder. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.
