The short answer
With borderline personality disorder (BPD), your goals, values and sense of who you are can change with your mood or the people around you. The diagnostic manual calls this identity disturbance, a self-image or sense of self that is unstable in a marked and lasting way, and it is one of the nine criteria for BPD. It makes change harder, because the person who chose a goal keeps moving. A steadier self can be built, a piece at a time.
BPD is often recorded in NHS letters as emotionally unstable personality disorder (EUPD). Of all its features, an unstable sense of self can be the hardest to put into words. This post looks at how self-image shapes your ability to change, why that’s harder with BPD, and what helps you build a self that holds steady for longer.
Start hereChronic emptiness and identity in BPDThe hollow feeling, the shifting self, and what helpsWhat does an unstable self-image feel like?
People describe it in many ways. You might recognise some of these:
- You take on the opinions, music and even the way of speaking of whoever you’re closest to.
- Your career plan changes every few months, each time with total certainty.
- You feel like a good person in the morning and a fraud by the evening.
- When you’re alone, you’re not sure who you are at all.
- Someone asks what you enjoy, and your mind goes blank.
This often sits alongside a feeling of emptiness. If there’s no settled “me” to come home to, the inside can feel hollow.
How does self-image affect your ability to change?
The psychologist Carl Rogers described two versions of the self. The real self is how you see yourself now. The ideal self is who you think you should be. Rogers argued that people feel more settled when the two are close, a state he called congruence, and more distressed when the gap is wide.
With BPD, that gap can be huge and unstable at once. The ideal self is often set out of reach: never angry, never needy, always coping. The real self swings between “I’m fine, I’ve got this” and “I’m a terrible person”. Change is hard to sustain when your starting point keeps moving and the finish line is out of reach.
Four ways a shifting self gets in the way
- Goals tied to a person. You take up running because a new partner runs. When the relationship ends, the goal goes with it.
- All or nothing. One missed day turns into “I’m someone who always fails”, and you stop.
- Shame after a slip. Shame says the problem is you, so it feels pointless to try again.
- A borrowed identity. A diagnosis, a role or a group can become the whole of who you are, leaving little room for other parts of you to grow.
Why is identity unstable in BPD?
There’s no single answer. Many people with BPD grew up where their feelings were ignored, punished or unpredictable, so they learned to watch others for every clue and become whoever kept them safe. A strong fear of rejection keeps that habit going in adult life. BPD and childhood trauma explains the link without assuming everyone with BPD has a trauma history.
Where does self-esteem fit in?
Low self-esteem often sits alongside a shaky self-image: self-doubt, harsh self-talk and putting everyone else first. In this short video I talk about why self-esteem matters and how you can start building a kinder relationship with yourself.
How can you build a steadier sense of self?
Nobody finds a fixed identity in one go. A steadier self tends to grow from small, repeated acts. These are places to start.
Notice what has stayed the same
Make a list of things that have been true of you for years, whatever your mood: a song you’ve loved since school, the way you are with animals, a sense of humour, a stubborn streak. These threads are part of you, even on days that feel blank.
Write your values down on a steady day
Pick three to five things that matter to you, such as honesty, creativity or looking after people. Keep the list on your phone. On a hard day, read it before you make a big decision.
Choose small goals that belong to you
Ask of any goal: “Would I still want this if nobody knew about it?” Start with something you can do in ten minutes, and do it on bad days as well as good ones. Small, repeated actions are how a sense of self takes shape.
Hold two things at once
Dialectical behaviour therapy (DBT) teaches “both/and” thinking. “I lost my temper, and I’m a caring person” is truer than either half alone. It shrinks the swing between all good and all bad.
How therapy helps with identity
Identity work is slow, and it needs a relationship that stays steady while you change. In my work we use DBT-informed skills to calm the swings, then schema-informed therapy to look at the deep beliefs about yourself that formed early, such as “I’m defective” or “I only matter when I’m useful”. Schema-informed therapy explains how that works. All of it runs alongside any care from your GP or NHS team, never as a replacement. Working with a BPD therapist describes the first steps.
Questions about self-image and BPD
Is an unstable sense of self always a sign of BPD?
No. Many people question who they are at times, for example in their teens and twenties or after a big loss. In BPD, the instability lasts and affects many parts of life. Only a qualified clinician can diagnose BPD.
Why do I become a different person around different people?
Many people with BPD learned early to read other people’s moods fast and adapt to stay safe. It was a clever way to cope at the time. Therapy helps you notice when it’s happening and choose what to keep.
Can your sense of self become more stable?
For many people it does, with time, therapy and practice. Change tends to come from small, consistent actions and steady relationships, more than sudden insight.
Is identity disturbance the same as dissociation?
They’re different, though they can overlap. Identity disturbance is about an unstable sense of who you are. Dissociation is feeling detached from your body, thoughts or surroundings, often under stress.
Sources
- American Psychiatric Association (2013). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fifth edition (DSM-5): borderline personality disorder, criterion 3, identity disturbance.
- Rogers, C. R. (1959). A theory of therapy, personality and interpersonal relationships, as developed in the client-centered framework. In S. Koch (ed.), Psychology: A Study of a Science, volume 3. New York: McGraw-Hill.
- NHS. Borderline personality disorder: symptoms.
- Linehan, M. M. (2015). DBT Skills Training Manual, second edition. New York: Guilford Press (dialectical thinking).
