Need help right now? 999 NHS 111, option 2 Samaritans 116 123 Text SHOUT to 85258

Book a free 30-minute call Call 07825 599340

Skills and self-help

Why “Just Stop the Thought” Doesn’t Work With BPD, and What Does

Pushing anxious thoughts away tends to make them louder. Here is why, and how DBT’s STOP skill helps you pause the action when BPD (EUPD) feelings surge.

A kettle coming to the boil on a kitchen worktop, steam rising beside a waiting mug

The short answer

Pushing an anxious thought away tends to bring it back stronger. In a well-known 1987 experiment, people told not to think about a white bear thought about it more afterwards. With borderline personality disorder (BPD), where feelings rise fast, a better aim is to stop the action and leave the thought alone. The STOP skill from dialectical behaviour therapy (DBT), developed by psychologist Marsha Linehan, gives you four steps for that moment.

If you live with BPD, which NHS letters often call emotionally unstable personality disorder (EUPD), an anxious thought seldom arrives on its own. It brings a pounding heart and an urge to do something now: send another text, cancel the plan, check one more time. This post explains why fighting the thought backfires, how STOP works in that moment, and what to do with the worry once the urge has passed.

Start hereDBT-informed skills therapyHow I teach STOP and the other DBT skills one to one

Why can’t you just stop an anxious thought?

The advice sounds sensible. Notice the worry, tell yourself “stop”, and think about something else. Some older therapy methods taught a version of this called thought stopping.

The white bear problem

In 1987 the psychologist Daniel Wegner and his colleagues asked people to say aloud whatever came into their heads for five minutes, while trying not to think of a white bear. They rang a bell each time it slipped in. Nobody could keep it out. Afterwards, when they were allowed to think about the bear, they thought about it more than people who had been free to think about it from the start. Wegner called this a paradoxical effect: trying to suppress a thought can feed the very preoccupation you’re fighting.

The same research found something that helped. People given a specific other thought to turn to were less caught up with the bear later.

Why it’s harder with BPD

BPD involves emotions that rise fast, hit hard and take a while to settle. A thought such as “they’re going off me” becomes, within seconds, a tight chest, a hot face and a strong pull to act.

Ordering yourself to stop thinking it can also add a second layer: “What’s wrong with me that I can’t switch this off?” Now there’s shame on top of the fear. BPD episodes and triggers explains how one moment can build into a storm.

What is the DBT STOP skill?

STOP belongs to the distress tolerance skills in DBT, the therapy Marsha Linehan developed for people with BPD. Distress tolerance means getting through a painful moment without making it worse. STOP is short on purpose, because it has to work when your thinking is at its foggiest.

StepWhat you doWhat it can sound like
StopFreeze for a few seconds. Don’t speak, type or move towards the urge.“Hands still. Nothing has to happen this second.”
Take a step backPut space between you and the trigger: phone face down, leave the room, one long breath out.“I can come back to this in ten minutes.”
ObserveNotice what’s going on inside you and around you, and separate facts from guesses.“I’m having the thought she’s angry. What I know is she hasn’t replied.”
Proceed mindfullyAsk what you want from this situation, and which action helps that or harms it.“I want this friendship. What would protect it tonight?”

STOP never asks you to get rid of the anxious thought. It can stay in the room while you decide what to do with your hands, your phone and your voice.

What does STOP look like in a real moment?

Say you sent a friend a message at lunchtime and by mid-afternoon there’s no answer. The thought lands: “I’ve upset her. She’s done with me.” Before long you’re drafting a second message, then a third.

  1. Stop. Thumbs off the screen. Phone on the table.
  2. Take a step back. Walk to the kitchen and make a drink. Breathe out for longer than you breathe in, a few times.
  3. Observe. “My chest is tight. I’m guessing she’s angry. The fact is she hasn’t replied for three hours on a workday.”
  4. Proceed mindfully. “A third message would make me feel worse tomorrow. I’ll wait until this evening.”

The anxious thought may still be there at the end, but it didn’t make the decision for you. STOP feels clumsy at first, so I ask people to rehearse it on small irritations, such as a slow queue, before they need it for the big ones.

What helps with the anxious thought itself?

Once the urge has passed, you can turn to the worry. These approaches tend to work better than trying to delete it.

Name it as a thought

Put “I’m having the thought that…” in front of it. “I’m having the thought that everyone at work thinks I’m useless” is easier to look at than “Everyone thinks I’m useless”. DBT calls this observing and describing, and it’s one of the core mindfulness skills.

Give your attention a job

Wegner’s finding points the way. Pick something specific that needs your mind: count every blue object in the room, do a word puzzle, or phone someone and ask about their day. Vague distraction drifts back to the worry.

Book the worry for later

Write the worry down and set a time to look at it, maybe 6pm. Some worries need action and will still be on the list. Others look different once your body has calmed down.

Look after the body doing the worrying

Anxious thoughts get louder on too little sleep, an empty stomach, too much caffeine or the morning after drinking. DBT’s PLEASE skills cover these basics, and BPD and sleep looks at nights in more depth. For TIPP, ACCEPTS and self-soothe, see the guide to distress tolerance skills.

When to get help

If anxious thoughts are steering your relationships, your work or your nights, it helps to practise skills on your own hardest moments with someone beside you. I teach STOP and other DBT-informed skills one to one, in Edgbaston or online, alongside your GP or NHS team, never instead of it. I’m a PESI Certified DBT Skills Practitioner, but I don’t offer the full programme with its group and phone coaching. Working with a BPD therapist explains what I do offer.

If the anxiety comes with thoughts of ending your life or hurting yourself, call NHS 111 and choose option 2, or Samaritans free on 116 123, day or night. In an emergency, call 999.

Questions about anxious thoughts and STOP

Is thought stopping the same as the DBT STOP skill?

No. Thought stopping is an older technique where you order a thought to go away. DBT’s STOP skill pauses your actions and lets the thought be. The second approach fits better with what research shows about suppressing thoughts.

How long does STOP take?

Anything from a few seconds to a few minutes. The first step can be a single breath with your hands still. With practice, the four steps start to run together.

What if STOP doesn’t work when I’m very distressed?

Some moments are too intense for any thinking skill. Then it helps to calm your body first, with skills such as cold water on your face or paced breathing, and come back to STOP after. In therapy we work out which skills fit you.

Can I use STOP if I don’t have a BPD diagnosis?

Yes. DBT skills were built for people with BPD, but anyone can use them. Many people with anxiety and no diagnosis find STOP useful.

Sources

  1. Wegner, D. M., Schneider, D. J., Carter, S. R. and White, T. L. (1987). Paradoxical effects of thought suppression. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 53(1), 5–13.
  2. Linehan, M. M. (2015). DBT Skills Training Manual, second edition. New York: Guilford Press (distress tolerance: STOP; emotion regulation: PLEASE; mindfulness: observe and describe).
  3. NHS. Borderline personality disorder: treatment (dialectical behaviour therapy).
Call 07825 599340 Book a free call